| Author | Message |
flower
12 posts |
#5876 2008-01-29 17:04 GMT |
|
Hi all, I just visited my parents this past week. (they are 70) and my step father got a Herpes Zoster Vaccine to help prevent shingles. He had chicken pox as a child, so he has the virus laying dormant in his body. The CDC has voted to make the vaccine routine at age 60.
Anyway, given that HZ is suspected in BP, I was wondering if anyone here has considered having the vaccine to prevent recurrences of BP?? Thoughts? Would you get it? Is it worth it??? Here's a little info: Shingles is a painful disease caused by reactivation of dormant varicella zoster virus, or VZV. Best known as the virus that causes chickenpoxchickenpox, VZV is a herpesherpes virus that can come back with a vengeance when a person's immunity wanes with age, disease, or immunity-suppressing drugs. Without vaccination, about 20% of people who have had chickenpox eventually will get shingles. A person who lives to be 85 has a 50% chance of getting shingles. I wonder if wonder what the odds are of someone getting BP after a certain age because they have this virus in their body?? |
|
LoBo
2119 posts |
#5877 2008-01-29 18:18 GMT |
|
Hi flower, good to see you again.
They are pretty strict about the age limit for the HZV vaccine. I haven't researched the reason for this, but I think it might be difficult to get it before the age of 60.
|
|
|
Lois
|
|
Bob Tucker
145 posts |
#5878 2008-01-30 06:50 GMT |
|
Good Morning Flower,
It is an interesting questiion tht you bring up. I was 65 at the time of BP onset. Six weeks prior to the onset I received the Zoster vaccine and my question is, are they related? I reported the incident to Merck and haven't heard anything from them other than the fill out the questionaire. My wife also recived the vaccine and she hasn't had any side effets. Could have been just the fickle finger of fate?? I've Had BP for seven months now and making some progress. Have a great day. Bob |
|
flower
12 posts |
#5879 2008-01-30 10:00 GMT |
|
Hi Lois, thanks for the welcome! Good to see you too. I haven't researched it much either, so I guess I should put that on my list of things to do. I think I will ask my Dr. too, when I go in for a check-up in March. I consider myself very lucky that I've gone 21 years without a recurrence, but I wonder if the odds will go up with age as does shingles???
Hi Bob, Herpes Zoster has been suspected as a cause for BP. I have never had Chicken Pox, but I do get cold sores from time to time, so I know I have that virus in my body. I contracted BP when I was 8 months pregnant, when women are 3 times more likely to get BP than non-pregnant women. However, until some real research is done, we may never know what actually causes BP. Of course, today, BP is, by definition, facial paralysis of no known origin. So a true diagnosis of BP should only be given after medical tests are given to rule out other causes, such as Lyme disease, tumors, etc. Glad to hear you are making progress. I am still getting new movement after 21 years. Crazy, huh??? Don't you just love this disease??? NOT! LOL Hang in there!! |
|
Bob Tucker
145 posts |
#5880 2008-01-30 11:51 GMT |
|
Yup. Seven months now and I'm doing PT. Slow progress and I am making some progress, SLOW. My mother had ABP 40+ years ago and she is now 96. She recovered within a month with no residual problems.
As my wife reminds me, "at least it wasn't a stroke". I am thankful for that. I've been very active, and this tood some getting use to. Oh well, life keeps moving on. I'll keep you posted if I hear anything. Bob |
|
LoBo
2119 posts |
#5881 2008-01-30 12:20 GMT |
|
Actually, Herpes Zoster causes Ramsay Hunt Syndrome, not BP. HZV (chicken pox and shingles virus) is proven to cause Ramsay Hunt Syndrome, which is very similar to BP, but can be more serious and can affect more than just the CN VII.
Herpes Simplex I (cold sore, whitlows herpes, cytomegalo virus) is believed to be the cause of BP, but as Flower said...there's no proof. BP is idiopathic. HSV-1 usually establishes latency in the trigeminal ganglion, a collection of nerve cells near the ear. From there, it tends to recur on the lower lip or face. HSV 2 (genital)usually sets up residence in the sacral ganglion at the base of the spine. But it's possible for HSV 2 to reside in the trigeminal ganglion, and HSV 1 to reside at the base of the spine. So either could be the cause of BP. |
|
|
Lois
|
|
flower
12 posts |
#5882 2008-01-30 12:33 GMT |
|
Thanks for the clarification Lois. It's been so long since I've thought about this stuff, I had forgotten the subtleties.
I need to find a place for PT or NMR. Lois, any suggestions? I've been to that BP site that I've seen you recommend before, and the Dr. listed there for my area isn't in practice or moved or something...can't find the clinic. |
|
LoBo
2119 posts |
#5883 2008-01-30 13:19 GMT |
|
I don't know which center you tried, Flower. Do you still have the link to that site? That is my source of info. I know that one of the doctors at the Houston center is not there anymore, but I believe that it's still functioning with a good Dr. Deneka, one of our members, would have more info on that. She lives in Houston and is treated there.
|
|
|
Lois
|
|
flower
12 posts |
#5887 2008-01-31 11:12 GMT |
|
Hey Lois, I don't have that link anymore. Can you send it to me and I can tell you which center I tried. I have talked with Deneka about the center in Houston, asking if she could get a referral to me for a Dr. in the Dallas area, but I haven't heard back from her. I know she is really happy with the Dr. she has. Maybe I should ping her again. BTW, the change in your face due to your Botox is amazing! Congrats! Jayne
Back to edit: I found the site, thanks to Brad's post. These are the centers near me: Clinical Center for Auditory, Vestibular, and Facial Nerve Disorders Univ. of Texas, Southwestern Medical Center Dallas, Texas Peter S. Roland, M.D., Medical Director of Clinical Center 800-688-8678, 214-648-8678 Went there, they offered NO help or hope. Center for Neurological Disorders Fort Worth, Texas Andrew Houtz, PhD 817-336-0551 Ok, when I called this one a few months back the phone # didn't work, but now it does. The person who answered the phone doesn't know if they do NMR or not, but is supposed to call me back. I'll let you know what I find out. This post was edited by flower (2008-01-31 11:26 GMT, 739 days ago) |
|
LoBo
2119 posts |
#5892 2008-01-31 13:49 GMT |
|
Hmm..Todd on the BPIS, just today recommended Andrew Houtz to someone who asked for a good physical therapist in his area. Keep trying.
Thanks for the comments about my Botox. Yes, I'm very pleased with the results. You have to remember that those are not moving pictures tho. I have only about 75-80% recovery, so a lot of spots still don't work and I do look quite wonky when I talk, laugh, etc. But I'm sure I think I look a lot worse than I actually do....don't we all? |
|
|
Lois
|
|
DebbieL
1173 posts |
#5893 2008-01-31 15:12 GMT |
|
You look wonderful Lois. Yes, I'm prejudiced because you look SO much better than I do.. but I still think you look great. Add to that the fact that you don't look ANYWHERE near your actual age!!
|
|
|
Debbie
|
|
LoBo
2119 posts |
#5894 2008-01-31 16:06 GMT |
Thank you!But you are being too modest. You look mahvelous dahling! I know you want that lovely smile you had as a 20 year old, but no one would guess you've had BP so many times nor that you are your age. |
|
|
Lois
|
|
sage
417 posts |
#5905 2008-02-03 06:46 GMT |
Quote Yes, currently it is approved only for people 60 and above. The clinical studies were done on this population, and the reason is that with age, the body's immunity declines. The vaccine was found to be most effective for people 60-69 yrs old. Bob, Flower, As mentioned, the shingles vaccine is against shingles and is not supposed to give you BP. It is however a live vaccine (but weakened) and it is not recommended for people with weak immune systems- people with HIV, or patients on immunosuppresive drugs. Bob, as far as this vaccine giving you BP- my guess is- probably not. However, it is possible that you may already have had weak immune system and the vaccine caused further stress on your immune system and caused BP (which is thought of due to herpes and not varicella). Most of us with BP got it because one way or another our immune systems were most likely weak at the time. Bob, were you by chance taking any immunosuppressive drugs for any condition at the time or prior to when you got BP? or when got the shingles vaccine? and equally importantly did your doctor check you for shingles? good thing you reported to Merck. |
|
Bob Tucker
145 posts |
#5906 2008-02-03 08:13 GMT |
|
Sage,
the only other drugs that I am on are for control of blood pressure. Before I retired (Nov 2006) I had been traveling for Dept of Defense to all the exotic places, Haiti, Saudi Arabis, Bosnia, Kosovo, and Iraq. Imy last visit to Iraq was about two months before I developed BP. I have my doubts that the vaccine was the primary cuase of BP however, it was only thing that was different in my life style. My wife recived the vaccine aobut six weeeks before I did ( I was in Iraq at the time). Perhaps it was just my time. I think I maed the right deision in trying to prevent shingles. It is 7 months now, I had the gold weight implant about three months after the onset, some folks thought it was early, however, I did and still think it was the right decision. I saw Drs at the Universityh of Cincinnati Medical center, booth the head of the ENT department and a neurosurgeon. They both see pts on the same day to try and decide a course of action. MRI showed no abnormality. ENT recommended a PT who is taking things slowly. At one time he mentioned eloectrical stim only as a last resort. After asking question on this forum, I decided to wait before heading down that path. PT or something has made a difference. PT rating went from about 3, to 20 and last visit in December was 45. I see him agian this week. Support from this forum has been GREAT!! Thanks. Bob |
|
sage
417 posts |
#5907 2008-02-03 09:04 GMT |
|
Bob,
The shingles vaccine is unlikely to directly give you BP because it is against shingles/varicella and BP is thought of as herpes mediated. Shingles is Ramsay-hunt (causes FP/facial paralysis which is varicella mediated) and not BP. Sometimes Ramsay (varicella) can be misdiagnosed as BP, if there are no visible lesions. Also it is indicated that the approved shingles vaccine is also not supposed to give you shingles because it is a attenuated (albeit live vaccine). The only 'extrapolated' connection between shingles vaccine and BP 'could' be via an indirect association i.e. vaccine causing a stress to your already stressed-out immune system, not so likely, but possible. Hope this helps. Hang in there. I also think that getting the shingles vaccine was probably a good idea. |
|
Bob Tucker
145 posts |
#5908 2008-02-03 11:04 GMT |
|
Sage,
thanks for the information. I am amazed how much information there is on this forum. Thanks to all who have helped me. I'm sure that many of the questions have een asked before and will be asked again. I understand that the lo9nger you have the issues with the nerves the greater the li8kely hood of residual damage. My wife told me early on, " be thankful it wasn't a stroke." I have repeated that many times and will continue to do so. Thanks for all your help. Bob |
|
DebbieL
1173 posts |
#5909 2008-02-03 11:16 GMT |
|
I have a friend who is 58 yrs old and was allowed to have the shingles vaccine because she has lupus along with other serious health issues, and has had many episodes of shingles. So far so good for her, no new episodes of shingles since the vaccine.
My husband (45 yrs old) is currently dealing with shingles. He had chicken pox as a child, has a cold sore at least once a year, and previously had two episodes of herpes of the eye. He's on famvir(antiviral) and meds for the pain, but is absolutely miserable. If that vaccine can keep you from dealing with shingles Bob, it was well worth it. |
|
|
Debbie
|
|
Bob Tucker
145 posts |
#5910 2008-02-03 11:50 GMT |
|
Debbie,
My mother and an aunt both had shingles and after seeing the misery they went through my wife and I decided to go for the vaccine. I agree, we think it was worth it. I think many of us had chicken pox as a child. the feeling then was to have chicken pox before you started school and some parents actually visited friends whose children had it so they could expose their children before school started. Oh well, things will improve. Bob |
|
LoBo
2119 posts |
#5911 2008-02-03 13:31 GMT |
|
My husband went for his shingles vaccine, but couldn't remember ever having chicken pox. So the Dr. gave him a blood test, and sure enough...he never had chicken pox. So...they gave him the chicken pox vaccine! Now he can't get chicken pox, so he also can't get shingles.
Debbie, it's good to know that one can have the shingles vaccine if they've already had shingles. I've had it twice. I think I'll check on this and get the vaccine, if possible. |
|
|
Lois
|
|
sage
417 posts |
#5913 2008-02-03 15:09 GMT |
|
Physicians have some liberty to prescribe FDA unapproved uses of medications in the US, under certain situations/conditions, which means that even if it is not approved by the FDA for such use or scope of use, but upon the physicians discretion, it can happen. It can be a delicate issue and sometimes can result in heavy liabilities.
Shingles vaccine is currently only approved for 60 and above but in your friend's case, Debbie, getting a shingles vaccine at 58 which is obviously pretty close to 60 and with the shingles history and other medical conditions she has, it makes sense. Lobo: one thing to keep in mind is that the two vaccines are different: i.e chicken pox vaccine and varicella zoster vaccine (shingles). Varicella Zoster Vaccine (shingles) is more potent than chicken pox vaccine. It makes sense, that your husband was given chicken pox vaccine after they checked his blood. In the US it is assumed that almost all people born here before 1980 are immune to varicella (chicken pox) and they can get shingles vaccine regardless of their history with chicken pox. If the person in not born in the US, they recommend a blood test. Did your husband's doctor specifically say that he will not need shingles vaccine, ever? i.e. that the chicken pox vaccine he got will prevent him from getting shingles? If the varicella vaccine (chicken pox)can protect him against shingles/Zoster because he has been recently immunized, that would be pretty good I'd say- but I don't know if that is or is not valid. I remember reading that zoster vaccine should not be given to children for protection against chicken pox (makes sense), and chicken pox vaccine should not be given for protection from shingles (also makes sense because it is weaker in strength) The safety studies on shingles vaccine looks pretty good and it seems to be very safe. More studies are underway: safety and efficacy for 50-59 yrs, 70+ yrs, more safety studies on 60+ yrs. In a few years we will have more information, but based upon the reported adverse effects which occur in very very small percentage, it is probably a good idea to get the Zoster/shingles vaccine if you are 60 or above. Yes, you can get shingles vaccine even after having shingles. |
|
LoBo
2119 posts |
#5914 2008-02-03 15:18 GMT |
|
My husband was not born in the US. A blood test showed he never had chicken pox.
I just asked my husband and, of course, he can't remember any of it. But I'm sure he came home from the doc and said the blood test showed he'd never had chicken pox, so he was given the chicken pox vaccination. I asked him if he'd have to have the shingles vaccination and he said...no, since I won't get chicken pox, I won't get shingles. I told him to ask the doc the next time he goes...and I'll be sure to go with him! (wish they had a vaccine against memory loss!)I must go to the Dr. in two weeks. I'll ask about my husband then...and also about the shingles vaccine for me. |
|
|
Lois
|
|
sage
417 posts |
#5915 2008-02-03 15:54 GMT |
|
Lobo, yes, the first part is very clear and logical - that his blood test showed that he was not exposed to chicken pox virus so the doctor rightly gave him the chicken pox vaccine (as is also recommended). He needs to have the chicken pox immunity.
Since your husband has been 'recently' immunized against chicken pox, may be the doctor thinks that he will be protected from shingles later on. I have not come across anything that suggests this though, but could be. Most of us have been exposed to chicken pox/have immunity to it - but many still get shingles. Having immunity to chicken pox does not prevent shingles from happening later on, when general immune strength declines- which is the reason for getting shingles vaccine. May be because he was only recently immunized against chicken pox, that he is protected from shingles as well?? May be the chicken pox vaccine he got was stronger than the one given to children? which may have protection against shingles later on?? Yes do ask the questions and let us know what the doctor says. |
|
LoBo
2119 posts |
#5916 2008-02-03 16:31 GMT |
|
This is all quite confusing to me. I will surely ask the Dr.
Here's the way I'm understanding this.... My husband went to have a shingles vaccination, but the Dr. would only give it to him if he'd had chicken pox because: 1. He'd need to have had chicken pox in order to get shingles. 2. If he'd never had chicken pox, a chicken pox vaccine would prevent having chicken pox thus stop any chance of getting shingles. So he had the chicken pox vaccination. 3. However...the chicken pox vaccine is a live virus, so getting the vaccine will then cause the virus to live in the body, thus making it possible to have shingles? 4. He will now need to get the Shingles vaccine since the chicken pox vaccination has put the virus into his system? Now...Wikepedia says that both chicken pox and shingles are caused by the same virus...VZV. It goes on to say that children are given Varevax and it's been proven to last over 10 years and those breakthrough cases are mild. Though VZV causes both chicken pox and shingles...the vaccinations have different names...Varevax for chicken pox, Zostivax for shingles. I will ask if there are different ingredients in these two vaccines, or if it's just a matter of dosage. If my husband was given a dosage of Varevax that should last over 10 years, he will be too old to have the shingles Zostivax when the 10 years have passed. Hmmmm I'm really going to ask some questions when I see the doc. I hope he hasn't put my husband in danger of having shingles.
|
|
|
Lois
|
|
sage
417 posts |
#5923 2008-02-05 12:02 GMT |
|
Yup those are the two vaccines I was talking about- Varivax and Zostavax.
I think the doctor would have said something if he/she thought your husband needed shingles vaccine later on, but check with the doctor in anycase. Don't worry about your husband getting chicken pox from the vaccine and then shingles. Imagine the other way around- not having the chicken pox vaccine, more likelihood of getting the chicken pox and then also shingles. I was trying to find if people with varivax have gotten chicken pox...don't think I found anything credible. Even if it happens, it is very mild form I think. There may be a very small chance of shingles with varivax...it is not completely ruled out (I think). And don't quote me for this one: I seem to remember reading way back (I even posted here about it) that shingles vaccine prevents reactivation of varicella, but not a primary chicken pox infection. Makes sense from many angles. It is made in a way to work against reactivation! This is the key I think. This is why I think shingles vaccine is not used to prevent chicken pox (and the potency issue) Let us know what the doctor says...it is better to have questions! at least now you are aware of all these things which can only be good. |
|
LoBo
2119 posts |
#5924 2008-02-06 15:35 GMT |
|
I had to see the Dr. earlier than expected. I've got a sinus infection, so went today. I asked about the chicken pox vaccine.
The PA told me that the chicken pox vaccine prevents chicken pox, so my husband will not get shingles if he never can get chicken pox. I asked about the strength of the vaccine. She said they give adults double the strength that they give children. She said there should never be need for him to get the shingles vaccine. She thinks that since I've already had shingles, I have antibodies and would not advise that I get the shingles vaccine. I might check on this more at a later date. Now my next adventure...colonoscopy. Prep tomorrow...yuck, colonoscopy on Friday. A necessary evil. I'll be glad when it's over.
|
|
|
Lois
|
|
HiDrr
264 posts |
#5925 2008-02-06 16:00 GMT |
|
Lois (and Sage),
This has been a great thread - very informative. Now, Lois, I am sorry you have to go through that c-word adventure, but am so glad you are being proactive with your health. Knowing you to be very health-conscious I am happy to hear you have scheduled the dreaded deed and going through with it - I will say little prayers for you tomorrow as you go through the prep (the worst part) and continue to pray for you through the weekend. Hope it all comes out ok in the end (oops) - Good Luck and Hooray for you! |
|
|
Heidi
|
|
DebbieL
1173 posts |
#5927 2008-02-06 18:00 GMT |
|
Best of luck Lois! I had my first one in Nov, it actually wasn't a big deal, and it was great to hear the doctor say - - you have a perfectly normal colon, and here are the pictures to prove it!!
|
|
|
Debbie
|
|
LoBo
2119 posts |
#5928 2008-02-06 19:15 GMT |
|
Thanks friends! Yes...I feel pretty good about myself getting up the nerve to do this. I hope my doc will say the same thing to me, Debbie.
So, the jello is made, lots of juices and flavored sparkling water in the fridge, a couple cans of beef and chicken broth...Powerade to replace electrolytes...I'm all set for my liquid cuisine. I'll let you know how it goes. I've talked to a lot of people who've had this dreaded experience...they all say the prep is worse than the test. What did you eat after in was done, Debbie? |
|
|
Lois
|
|
DebbieL
1173 posts |
#5929 2008-02-07 05:42 GMT |
|
Lois, easing into solid food again is a good idea. I had a nice thick soup for my first meal, and gradually got back to normal eating. Remember not to eat too much roughage right away. Your body will be very empty! I don't think I ate salad for a couple of days, though I ate a banana that first day and soft vegetables. You'll be fine! I just hope your doctor is as funny and pleasant as mine. When he came in the room afterwards to tell us the results, he said "Hi, how are you doing?" Andrew said he almost replied "just waiting for the doctor!" He's a very short, bearded, almost rough looking happy go lucky doctor. I know if I had a problem, his personality would make it easier to cope with. Good luck drinking! Oh, btw, I found turkey broth to be the tastiest!
|
|
|
Debbie
|
|
sage
417 posts |
#5930 2008-02-07 08:28 GMT |
|
Lobo,
Glad your husband got a double dose of chicken pox vaccine, no booster shot needed later on, that he will not get chicken pox EVER, so no shingles vaccine needed for him, ever. Good news. The fact that you got shingles multiple times (you said you have had it twice) suggests that the shingles antibodies you have are not helping you combat it fully. Zostavax was not studied to see if it prevents shingles in people who have already had shingles. Currently studies are underway for this scenario. But if you are 60 and above, you can get shingles vaccine whether or not you have had shingles. Since you are above 60, you should have no problem getting a prescription for shingles vaccine, even if you have had shingles. If I were you, I would get the shingles vaccine, specially since it seems to be so safe. But it is your call. |
|

Next page


Thank you!
But I'm sure he came home from the doc and said the blood test showed he'd never had chicken pox, so he was given the chicken pox vaccination. I asked him if he'd have to have the shingles vaccination and he said...no, since I won't get chicken pox, I won't get shingles.
I told him to ask the doc the next time he goes...and I'll be sure to go with him! (wish they had a vaccine against memory loss!)